[sugar] Journal: two quick suggestions

[Edward Cherlin]

On Thu, Feb 28, 2008 at 11:41 AM, Eben Eliason <eben.eliason at gmail.com> wrote:
>
> > while toying around with the Journal today I had two ideas about the
> > "anything" and "anytime" filter functions:
> >
>
> Both interesting ideas...
>
> > "anything": Apart from offering activities and file-types as
> > filter-options I'm thinking that it might make sense to also offer an
> > option for different subjects that kids will have at school. So things
> > like "Maths", "English", whatever... My thought is that many activities
> > will be started and resumed in a certain class-context and offering
> > such a filter could help them to quickly find related matters.
>
> One of our fears here is the proliferation of options within this menu,
> which could eventually limit its usefulness, and is the reason we chose to
> limit to some "primitive" types and the installed activities.

A common way to address this problem is to make the menu customizable
with user-defined filters and the ability to remove unneeded filters
(but keep the option to restore them later). Google mail is an
example, where users can create their own tags and set filters to
apply them automatically.

The usual alternative is folders, as in Moodle.

> One can
> imagine that the "subject" of an activity is actually subjectively defined,
> and even when it's relatively clear, we might wind up with some for each of
> "math", "geometry", "trigonometry", "algebra", etc.
>
> To make a similar functionality available, though, we've chosen to allow
> developers to supply a list of tags within the .info file for any given
> activities, which could include several subject related words, as well as
> more abstract or general terms like "game", "simulation", or "language".  We
> hope that the ability to search by broad terms such as "math" or "games"
> will then turn up a list of appropriately related activities.
>
> Having just typed this and then reviewing the wiki, I notice that this part
> of the spec doesn't appear to be there yet!  Can those familiar with this
> respond about the presence or absence of this capability?  If this isn't
> there, it should get a ticket.  It should be a pretty straightforward
> addition and simple to implement, it seems.
>
>
> > "anytime": Here it might make sense to add more informal filters such
> > as "5 grado", "2nd semester" or something along these lines.
>
> This one is actually much harder to do in a general way.  We chose, on
> purpose, to treat time in the relative sense with respect to the Journal.
> Instead of seeing a story you wrote on November 28, 2007 you might find a
> story you wrote "3 months ago".  This approach was chosen, in a sense, to
> internationalize (or perhaps simply generalize) the Journal with respect to
> time, so that school systems with widely different schedules (some might
> have class daily for one of every 3 months, for instance) can all take
> advantage of it.
>
>
> > Of course one could also argue that such information could be
> > explicitly added via the tags but I think a more implicit mechanism
> > could potentially make more sense.
>
> You can see how, in the former case, the tag model is still implicit, in a
> sense, when installing an activity.  In the latter case, I don't see any
> good way other than explicit tagging that doesn't have additional UI
> overhead/management to function.  I'm open to ideas here.
>
> Thanks for your feedback!
>
> - Eben
>
>
> _______________________________________________
>  Sugar mailing list
>  Sugar at lists.laptop.org
>  http://lists.laptop.org/listinfo/sugar
>
>



-- 
Edward Cherlin
End Poverty at a Profit by teaching children business
http://www.EarthTreasury.org/
"The best way to predict the future is to invent it."--Alan Kay